Union Leader Logo

Site Search

NH REAL ESTATE
search by town or realtor


Exact  Similar

Results in pop-up window

CLICK HERE to place an online ad for items valued under $500 for free.

Browse Opinion by Topic

A Scout vs. Congress: Bringing a victory for faith

Share on Facebook

Reader comments


FOR FOUR YEARS the architect of the U.S. Capitol has censored letters from constituents by removing political and religious messages. That outrageous policy was halted by a 17-year-old Ohio Boy Scout originally from New Hampshire.

Andrew Larochelle of Dayton, Ohio, whose grandfather Marcel is an Army veteran from Manchester, wanted to celebrate his attainment of the rank of Eagle Scout by giving his grandfather a flag that had been flown over the Capitol. He wrote this message to go on the certificate: "In honor of my grandfather Marcel Larochelle, and his dedication and love of God, country, and family."

Well, Stephen Ayers, acting architect of the Capitol, removed "God" from the message. Rules prohibited any mention of politics or religion, you see.

Larochelle contacted his representative, Rep. Michael Turner, R-Ohio, who got more than 100 members of Congress to petition House Speaker Nancy Pelosi to change the rule. Amazingly, Pelosi at first refused. But as the campaign got national attention, she relented.

Ayers rescinded the rule, saying, most correctly, that it was "beyond the scope of this agency's responsibilities to censor messages from members of Congress."

And so a 17-year-old Eagle Scout scored a win for free speech, religious tolerance and faith.

YOUR COMMENTS


BTW - My read of the editorial doesn't have the writer praising Pelosi: "Amazingly, Pelosi at first refused. But as the campaign got national attention, she relented."
- Tom, Campton

Stephen - the noble scout mentioned God, not any particular creed.

Why are liberal Democrats so afraid of God?
- Tom, Campton

Christians don't have the market cornered on a faith in G_d.

How do you know the Scout isnt Jewish?

I am pretty sure That they worshiped God before Christians did.
- Billy C, Andover

I agree with the editorial; however, I feel that this editorial plays to a feeling that somehow Christians and The Faithful are being victimized nowadays. The reason the UL felt worthy to write this piece was that the scout wanted to mention God, and this plays on the fears of some that everyone in the world is out to get Christians. The UL does not hesitate to attack the Democrats when they preach a "culture of victimhood", but this is an example that both parties use the victimhood game to mobilize their bases.
- Stephen Boyington, Chester

Stephen if the Eagle Scout wanted Islam more power to him. This isn't about celebrating one faith over another. This is about one person wanting something on a personal item. Had he been asking the phrase to be posted in side the capital dome that is one thing but asking that a gift given basically from him to his grandfather have the phrase removed is PC run amok.
- Brian Schwatka, Wakefield, NH

What would have been the reaction if the Eagle Scout wanted the citation to read: "In honor of my grandfather Marcel Larochelle, and his dedication to love of family, country and Islam."? Would the UL have praised Pelosi for allowing that to be read?
- Stephen Boyington, Chester

Hurray for Andrew Larochelle and common sense! All of this hypersensitivity and reluctance to mention God's name must go. After all, if you truly believe that there is no God ... you'd BETTER be right.
- Jim Turner, Edmond, OK

NOTE: If you have visited this page before, newer comments may be hidden. Press F5, or hold down the Ctrl key while reloading or refreshing the page. (Another option for Firefox users is the Clear Cache add-on.)