Union Leader Logo

Site Search

 Events Calendar

Brown case e-mails investigated

Share on Facebook

Reader comments

By STAFF AND WIRE REPORT

Police have arrested an Ed Brown sympathizer who sent a potentially threatening e-mail to Lebanon city councilors last Friday.

A longtime anti-government activist, Joseph Haas, 54, of Concord, sent the e-mail to all nine Lebanon city councilors, several state officials and New Hampshire State Police personnel.

"You all live in a dream land of lies, the father of which is the devil himself," Haas wrote in a section of the e-mail titled "city corruption." " Either you do your job, or get out of the way. WISE UP OR DIE. If the latter be your choice, then BE GONE with you NOW!"

Haas was arrested on his way to the town selectboard meeting Wednesday night on charges that he threatened a Lebanon city councilor by e-mail. He was released on personal recognizance bail

Haas claims the city and state are corrupt because paperwork relative to the federal seizure of the Browns' property in West Lebanon wasn't filed with the Secretary of State's office.

The property was seized June 7 to supplement Ed and Elaine Brown's unpaid federal income taxes while the convicted couple continues to defy federal authorities by refusing to surrender and serve prison time.

Haas, who was indicted in 2005 on allegations that he sent a threatening letter to Attorney General Kelly Ayotte, says he was exercising his right to free speech by writing the e-mail.

"There's no case here," he said in a voicemail left for a reporter yesterday. "It's just like our state slogan, 'Live Free or Die.' When you say that to somebody, do they take it like you're going to kill them? Of course not, so when I say, 'Wise up or die,' there's a similar common denominator there."

Haas indicated that he would attend the city council's July 18 meeting, "where and when you can talk this over to correct your misdeeds," he wrote.

Haas said Lebanon police should be investigating whether state law was violated during the seizure of the Browns' property. The law he cites in the e-mail, RSA 123:1, deals with the procedure for ceding land within the state to federal authorities for uses such as post offices, military bases "or other public buildings."

In the e-mail, Haas also requested information about the Lebanon Police Department's role in arresting Ed Brown in May 2005 and the activities of federal authorities in Plainfield and Lebanon on June 7, when another Brown supporter was detained for hours after inadvertently discovering federal agents near the Browns' house.

Much of Haas' e-mail is indecipherable in that it doesn't follow basic rules of grammar, but it was clear enough to alarm some of those who received it.

Haas submitted a comment to UnionLeader.com's this morning on its earlier version of this article. His statement appears below.

"It's the first time that I've encountered something like this," City Councilor Karen Liot Hill said. "These are threats, and I strongly believe in democracy. We should be arguing about ideas, and the best ideas should be winning, and I don't think there's a place for threats in a democracy."

Liot Hill said the city has handled the situation involving the Browns' case in a responsible manner.

Lebanon police Cpl. David Young said Detective Michael Roberts is investigating whether Haas committed a crime by sending the e-mail.

Haas, in a recent post to a Web forum about Ed and Elaine Brown, wrote that Roberts called him to ask how one of the city councilors would die.

"I said: I don't know how she's going to die! That's up to her and her God or god, or goddess, etc. under her own Article 5 religious rights. He thinks I KNOW something beyond belief, and wants to charge me with Criminal Threatening, but has to get me to fill in the blank. What does he think I am, a fortune teller?"

Young said police department policy prohibits Roberts from discussing the investigation.

The Browns sequestered themselves in their Plainfield home after a federal court jury convicted them in January on multiple felony charges of tax evasion. They were both sentenced in absentia to serve 63 months in federal prison April 24. They have said they will not be taken by the government.

Browns say they will either walk free, or die (27)
The Browns insist they won't back down
Feds say they can outwait the Browns (13)
Power, telephone, Internet access cut to Browns' home (13)

YOUR COMMENTS


"Wise up or die" is not a threat because it is not suggesting that the writer is going to kill anyone, only that he is telling someone what he wants them to do. "I'm gonna kill you" is a threat because the person is saying that they are going to do something to someone. "Wise up or die" falls in the same category as "Take a long walk off a short pier", "Why don't you just shoot yourself" and "Break a leg", as none of them indicate that the writer or speaker is threatening to do anything. While Mr. Haas' grammar is difficult to understand at times, the people who really need help with their grammar and reading comprehension are certain members of the Lebanon City Council and Police Department and anyone else who thinks that "Wise up or die" is a threat.
- Timothy Logsdon, Somersworth, NH

Mr./Mrs. Brown and Mr. Haas are not Americans, they have given up that right. They are a shameful example of selfish people that get stopped by a fed up society. The government that it taking a stand against these grandstanding clowns is my government representing me. I thank you.
- Ronald Phelps, Concord, NH

This state is one of the most wonderful places on earth, not only because it is beautiful, but because of it's freedom loving and gentle people.
It sounds like there are a lot of frustrated people here, and I certainly hope that the US Marshalls can handle this in a way all NH citizens will respect, and in a way no one in the peaceful town of Plainfield will be harmed or their rights violated.
- "Jode" (J. DeCosta), PO Box 775 Plymouth, NH

Maybe the Browns should read this, here is aquick explanation from forbes on Voluntary tax's.

LOS ANGELES - It says right there in the Internal Revenue Service's official instructions for filling out Form 1040 that the tax system is "voluntary." But you better wait before you file for a complete refund of withheld taxes. Voluntary "refers to our system of allowing taxpayers to determine the correct amount of tax and complete the appropriate returns, rather than have the government determine tax for them," the IRS declares in a statement.

To the agency, therefore, "voluntary" apparently means little more than "not done at gunpoint."
- Daniel, Bedford

Would somebody please correct Lebanon City Councilor Karen Liot Hill, as I'm forbidden to contact her per the terms of my release. She's got to know that we do not live in a "democracy" that Barbara Anderson of Epsom @ The Trojan Horse on Route 4 used to call a "mobocracy" where three wolves and two sheep vote for what they'll have for dinner. The Councilors pledge allegience to the flag of the United States of America and to the (Art. IV, Sec. 4) Republican form of government pre-scribed in the U.S. Constitution, so why don't they practice what they pledge!?
- Joseph S. Haas, Concord, New Hampshire 03302-3842

Telling someone to wise up or die contradicts live free or die in that a person is living free if they are not forced to be wise. Telling that free, unwise person to 'wise up or die' is most definitely a threat because it takes away the person's freedom of choice. If they don't meet Mr. Haas's definition of wise, the implication is they will be killed. Mr. Haas' statement that Wise Up or Die is the same as Live Free or Die is a very weak argument. Live Free or Die is a slogan. Wise Up or Die is a threat. There is a very distinct difference between the two phrases.
- Bryan Ledoux, Merrimack, NH

NOTE: If you have visited this page before, newer comments may be hidden. Press F5, or hold down the Ctrl key while reloading or refreshing the page. (Another option for Firefox users is the Clear Cache add-on.)