Union Leader Logo

Site Search

NH REAL ESTATE
search by town or realtor


Exact  Similar

Results in pop-up window

CLICK HERE to place an online ad for items valued under $500 for free.

Browse Opinion by Topic

Jonah Goldberg: Our gold star world of mediocrity

Share on Facebook

Reader comments

By JONAH GOLDBERG

WHILE PARENTS and politicians have been pounding the table demanding greater academic performance in the "Three R's," social scientists, psychologists and education bureaucrats have slowly but ingeniously reframed the battle onto more favorable turf. Rather than compete head-to-head in a battle we cannot win, these dedicated teachers and administrators have elevated the importance of the one area where no country can compete with us: self-esteem.

Nearly 25 years ago, the Reagan administration released "A Nation at Risk," a scathing indictment of the educational system, proclaiming, "If an unfriendly power had attempted to impose on America the mediocre educational performance that exists today, we might well have viewed it as an act of war."

A quarter-century after we declared war on mediocrity, some say it is time to face a painful truth: Mediocrity won. Now it's time to cut our losses and admit that this battle is lost.

Jonah Goldberg column logo

It's easy to see why defeatism and depression reign supreme. Every day the headlines announce how far behind we've fallen. Preschoolers in South Korea can recite the square root of pi to the 300th place. Chinese kids know the periodic tables even before the umbilical cord is cut. A half-naked Sri Lankan child just built the first fully functioning perpetual motion machine. The fact that his school has no electricity, desks or even a roof drives home that infrastructure investments aren't the answer.

This was the brilliant insight of America's educational industrial complex, which has worked tirelessly to make our kids think the most of themselves regardless of their accomplishments.

The unsung hero of this story is Fred Rogers of "Mister Rogers' Neighborhood." Few of us realized that the saccharine sage of preschool TV, who died in 2003, was preparing American youth for the rough-and-tumble world of global competition. Beneath that soft red sweater beat the heart of a warrior.

"You've made this day a special day," he said at the end of every show, "just by being you. You are the only person like you in this whole world. And people can like you just because you're you."

I remember during my own childhood how Saturday-morning cartoons were punctuated with public service announcements informing me that "the most important person in the whole wide world is you." Looking at me today, who can deny the basic truth of these ads?

More broadly, America's educational elite has built on this down payment of unqualified self-regard by redefining what it means to be educated. Rather than be educated about meaningless stuff -- dates, names, facts, figures and other trivia -- these selfless patriots have committed to drilling it into kids that no matter how "stupid" or "ignorant" they are on paper, in the real world they are brilliant and wonderful.

The payoff is all around us.

A study earlier this year titled "Egos Inflating Over Time," led by Jean Twenge of San Diego State University, found that -- you guessed it (Good for you!) -- egos are inflating over time. They concluded that America's youth are the most self-absorbed since we began testing.

Confirmation of Twenge's findings abound. CBS's "60 Minutes" profiled the so-called Generation Y, which is so fond of itself that employers cannot keep up. These new employees demand to be told how wonderful they are. They want to hear that nobody has ever photocopied better. They want a gold star for getting coffee. This demonstrates that our new educational regimen is showing real-world results. Teach a kid that merely having a pulse is a major accomplishment, and he'll carry that lesson for the rest of his life.

Sadly, despite this success, there has been a backlash. College professors resent having to teach students who want an A for showing up.

A recent op-ed in The Wall Street Journal decried the campaign to get rid of "thought competition." This isn't, as I had imagined, where kids spend math class daydreaming they are, say, Klingons endlessly challenging each other to fights to the death. Rather, it is where students compete to see who is best at math or writing.

We must resist such backsliding. Only by pressing our advantages can we remain No. 1. "Objective" criteria used by our competitors are self-evidently illegitimate because they make our kids feel bad.

We need to make each and every child such a bundle of unalloyed self-regard that together they become black holes of self-esteem, the centers not only of their own worlds but of the entire universe, from which no self-criticism can escape.

If we are going to leave no children behind, we must abandon the idea that being smart and accomplished makes you special. For only by getting rid of the idea that some people are special can you teach children that everyone is.

Jonah Goldberg's e-mail address is JonahsColumn@aol.com.

YOUR COMMENTS


Its tempting to say those who can, do. Those who can't, Teach. Unfortunately, or maybe fortunately, I know at least 2 teacher, maybe a couple more, who really do teach, they know self esteem comes from accomplishments, not undeserved pats on the back or "everyone wins" phony competitions.
- Jeff,, Goffstown

I think it was Boulder Colorado getting rid of the Valedictorian award because it might offend others that worked hard too.

Amazing.

And why? In the name of political correctness? And just wait..it will get worse as the nanny states step in more and more. Pretty soon "time out" will be considered cruel and unusual punishment (according to my 7yr old..it is). If we continue to pacify and indulge kids we cannot complain about how they turn out. We create the monsters and then wonder where they came from.

Something has got to give. We seem to be a country of extremes. Either control and belittle or let them run wild. There is middle ground people!
- Susan, Manchester

these same tomatoheads are going to be deciding on my health care needs when i retire...maybe i'll move to canada at that point...
- g talbot, new hampton

Jonah, Jonah, Jonah...

Don't you know that the nail that stands out is always the one to get hammered down? All this talk of moving away from mediocrity is insanity! Next you'll be expecting things like responsibility and accountability to be taught. Cooperation will soon follow and we all know how dangerous that can be. There might even be an outbreak of compassion and concern for your fellow citizens.

On the series side, well written column. It seems like all of this "looking out for number 1" is a whole lot of "number 2".
- Max, Manchester

NOTE: If you have visited this page before, newer comments may be hidden. Press F5, or hold down the Ctrl key while reloading or refreshing the page. (Another option for Firefox users is the Clear Cache add-on.)