Pot is medicine: Let the ill use it
Marijuana use can produce lots of outcomes that are not socially desirable. It also can alleviate horrible symptoms of numerous chronic illnesses and, recent research is showing, actually fight some types of cancer.
The psychological effects of marijuana use have been well-documented for decades. Its medical effects have been revealed more recently. They show without a doubt that smoking marijuana has significant benefits for some seriously sick people. With the growing body of evidence revealing just how helpful marijuana can be for some of the chronically ill, the case against making it available to them has gone up in smoke.
New Hampshire's House of Representatives has passed a bill, House Bill 648, to make the medicinal use of marijuana legal under tightly controlled circumstances. The bill would require a doctor's prescription and a state-issued permit for legal marijuana use. The amount a patient or his caregiver could possess would be limited to two ounces, six seeds and six plants.
As medical marijuana bills go, this one is narrowly crafted to alleviate the suffering of people with debilitating illnesses while avoiding a dangerous increase in the illicit drug trade. It might need some more tweaks before final passage, but overall it is well written.
Marijuana has been proven highly effective at alleviating the side effects of chemotherapy and other treatments for a long list of chronic illnesses, including cancer and glaucoma. It can even stimulate the appetites of cancer patients on chemotherapy, which notoriously weakens appetite. The National Cancer Institute confirms that inhaling smoked marijuana delivers these therapeutic benefits more effectively than taking pills that contain the same active ingredient.
New research even suggests that although smoking pot while young increases the odds of testicular cancer in men, marijuana can kill lung and brain cancer cells.
We understand the concerns of law enforcement officials who oppose this bill. But at this point, withholding the proven medical benefits of smoked marijuana from those extremely ill patients who cannot be helped by any other treatment would amount to a cruel deprivation of necessary medical care. The Senate should pass the bill.
Say this for Bill Binnie. When he gets caught in a lie, he doesn't shy from it. He turns it into an even bigger whopper.
If immigration officers and attorneys themselves have no confidence in the administration's handling of illegal aliens, why should the rest of us?
More Editorials >>>
- > Adams for council: A great choice in District 2
- > Editorial Cartoon: That Victory Thingy
- > Editorial Cartoon: Oval Office
- > Just crazy: The Discovery shooter (7)
- > Editorial Cartoon: New model (1)
- > Smearing Ayotte: The FRM mudslinging (36)
- > Editorial Cartoon: Not paying attention (9)
- > Obama on Iraq: 'Mission Accomplished' (29)
- > Editorial Cartoon: Iraq War medal (2)
- > Editorial Cartoon: Like riding a bike
- > Accident report: MPD's encouraging admission (18)
- > Forrester in the 2nd: She deserves a shot (10)
- > Editorial Cartoon: Replace your divots
- > Give Lynch credit: He's achieved so much (17)
- > Media myths: Obama vs. the Tea Party (29)

.jpg)

Print
Email
Mobile
Reader comments
Andrew Cline has been editorial page editor of the New Hampshire Union Leader since October of 2001. His writing has appeared in more than 100 newspapers and magazines, including The Wall Street Journal, The Washington Post, and National Review.
YOUR COMMENTS
Thank You,
Jeffrey Kennedy
- Jeff Kennedy, Boynton Beach, Florida
And it is also my ponion that I would rather see a man come home from work at nite and light up a joint to relax than crack open a beer.
Have you ever known of anyone beating his family after he smokes a joint? How many times however does it happen to alcoholics? On a daily basis.
- Gene, Allenstown
- SJT, NH
- Patrick, Berlin
- Patrick, Berlin
- ROBERT LEE, NILES,OHIO
I run the Concord Multiple Sclerosis Support Group for the National Multiple Sclerosis Society. The group frequently discusses alternative treatments, updated research or talk about current pharmaceutical companies.Some members use various drugs. Some use none at all. Some have tried Cannabis and it relieved the spasms in their legs. The use of Cannabis was done in a clandestine fashion to avoid being arrested. House Bill 648 would make sure; seriously ill patients, have a safe and legal access to Cannabis if their doctors recommend it.
I have had Multiple Sclerosis for several years and feel I should have the freedom to use anything at my disposal to relieve my suffering. One of the drugs I use is called baclofen. It has a nasty side effect if I decided to go "cold turkey" from the use of it.
"Abrupt discontinuation of baclofen may cause seizures and hallucinations." The use of Cannabis could be used as a tool in treating Multiple Sclerosis along with a cane, a walker or a wheelchair if necessary. It would at least give a victim of MS an option in their treatment. If you could walk a mile in my shoes you would understand.
- Richard Vincent, Loudon
This could make for a very interesting roundtable or series, if you wanted to make it one. There are a variety of possible positions: fully illegal, legal only within registered medical facilities to patients with prescriptions, legal for dispensing only by state-licensed growers to patients with prescriptions for home use, legal for production by patients with a prescription, legal for general use within state-controlled settings (similar to the way the state runs alcohol stores), all the way to complete legalization for general use. I would have to come down closer to the legalization end, not because I have any liking for mind-altering substances (including, say, alcohol), but because marijuana prohibition is having far more negative side effects (in terms of funding criminal organizations) than marijuana itself caused.
- Peter, Canterbury
After undergoing three intense rounds of chemo therapy treatments and years of daily suffering due to chronic back problems, I have firsthand knowledge to the benefits of using medical marijuana. During these past chemo treatments, I've also been prescribed Marinol for nausea and loss of appetite. In my experience, Marinol (synthetic THC) is greatly overated, highly expensive and lacks the medical benefits of using organic marijuana.
Kudo's to the many citizens of New Hampshire who support and have worked so hard toward the passing of HB 0648. Passage of this bill will bring positive results to everyone in our fine state.
.
- Dave, Goffstown
Second of all, Kathy B from Laconia is right. Judging by the number of people in support of this bill through these comments, you all need to speak up! The few whom are against this bill sure are.
Third of all, if the state of New Hampshire can profit from the horrible effects of alcohol abuse, then why, oh why, can they not profit from pot? There is a HUGE difference between the two that I have seen first hand. I've seen many people steal, drink rubbing alcohol, going through DTs, even saw my grandmother stabbed, all due to alcohol. The worst thing I've seen anyone due whilst on weed is eat all of my snack cakes. Read up on why pot is illegal in the first place (money that the cotton industry was afraid it would lose to hemp).
- Christopher, brentwood
- Howard, Cheyenne, WY
- Karen, Manchester
Nevermind the "medicinal effects". This is all about opening the door to legalization. So legalize it. I've never smoked it and never will. However, I'm all for anything that will make a large number of people more stupid...which in turn makes me look smarter. There's no need to raise your I.Q. if everyone else's is dropping. Same effect.
- Mark, Bedford
great job U.L.!
- Brandon, Goffstown
I for one PERSONALLY KNOW a brain cancer survivor from california. Chemo did not shrink his tumor, and when he started smoking pot it completely disappeared.
Its hard to argue facts:
1. Marinol doesn't help those who can't swallow it, and doesn't work as quickly and as powerfully as smoking or using a vaporizor (which, for all of you arguing that pot smoking is bad this is completely safe; no smoke involved)
2. It is PROVEN, through numerous studies (the number greatly outweighs studies arguing against) that it kills cancer cells
there is no argument
- Scott, Manchester
The problem I see is it's going to be hard to make sure you only have 6 seeds and only 6 plants, etc...., they don't take into consideration that some plants are going to be male which cannot be used and have to be thrown away unless your going to pollenate the female plant to make seeds you generally throw out the male plant and if you do pollenate you will have way more than 6 seeds but it will be worth to stay within the Laws and limits anyway to get the benifit of being able to use it.
If these people that are against it can only have "my" pain for one week I think they might change their minds if they knew that it would help them even reduce their pain 50%!!! When you are in constant pain 24/7 it effects your whole life and to be able to smoke a few puffs of a joint at night or during the day and get immediate relief/help from some of your pain I'm sure they would have different views on it.
I cannot understand why such a stigma with this herb, I wonder if any of these people that don't want this "Medical" Bill approved DRINK?" I'd put money on it that they either drink or smoke cigarettes!!! Which I think cost the Government, Hospitals, Insurance Comany's etc... more money then Marijuana ever could in yours your childs and your childs children's lifetime.
I applaud the Union Leader for it's stance on the subject. Good for you!!!
- Jim, Concord, NH
Local supermarkets have reported there is a run on potato chips, funyuns, and cheesy poofs. The state police have reported that the speed on the highway has slowed to 35 mph and Meadowbrook has added 3 Grateful Dead shows this summer.
- WS, Manchester
I have spent the last few years living in New Hampshire and know the people involved with this movement and after reading your post I understand where you're coming from and want to clarify some of your questions for you.
First I am a California native. I recently moved back and have had a wealth of education on how the Medical Marijuana works here.
Medi-Cal the state health insurance company that works hand in hand with Medicare, DOES actually provide insurance benefits for med marijuana.
Here, we have Co-ops or dispensaries, pretty much little shops that get licensed through the state to grow and provide for the approved users. They then order cannabis seeds from wholesalers that are generally not in this country and they grow the plants in secret warehouses that the public doesn't know about. After the cultivation process is complete, they fill their store with a variety of products ranging from edibles (chocolate cake, cupcakes, brownies, candies, lollipops, etc) that contain THC, various marijuana strains because depending on the type of marijuana it can provide a different effect, seeds, clones of cannabis plants, and paraphernalia (so to speak).
By setting up shops like this it takes the money out drug dealers hands and puts it in to a taxable, legitimate business. California racks in millions of dollars a year on medical marijuana taxes.
If you have any other questions feel free to email me at frrros@aol.com
- Forrest, Los Angeles, CA
I hope that this passes and they legalize it all together. They should pay more attention to the people who are addicted to alcohol and prescription drugs, because those are the drugs that kill people and harm families, not pot.
- S, Pelham
Nevertheless, it would be great to see the state stop spending money on eradication of marijuana, a process that will drive up the street price and the level of corruption the closer we get to 100%. The police resources will be necessary to combat the wave of tobacco smuggling that current government policy is certain to cause.
- Spike, Brentwood NH
However, as we see in editorials day after day, this paper will take any opportunity to criticize Democrats when they disagree with the position the Union Leader is taking. On this issue, the position of the Union Leader is in contrast to that taken by Republican leadership in the House and the Senate. GOP Chairman John H. Sununu said - in this paper, less than a month ago - that a House committee's support of medical marijuana "confirmed the Democratic agenda is coming out of San Fransisco."
Where is the Union Leader's criticism of Republicans when the two disagree on policy issues? Is the Union Leader's partisanship so entrenched that it won't even criticize Republicans when it is logical to do so? What does it say to readers when the UL won't even address the GOP chair calling their position part of a "San Fransisco" agenda?
- Dan, Manchester
Our tax money already keeps their kitchens filled and health insurance paid. What is your point Alex? This is about nothing more than providing relief for people suffering with a deadly disease. Would you feel better if we just took them out back and shot them?
Should we put a ban on prescription morphine and let people in pain suffer because you are worried about welfare abuse? Do you think only people on welfare get cancer? Are you afraid they will “pretend” to have cancer to get their “meds”? Pot is much cheaper to manufacture than
most pharmaceuticals that are legal. You put a seed in some dirt and add water. No need for a lab full of chemicals.
The idiotic drivel just keeps coming doesn't it? And people say using pot can make one paranoid...
How can you be afraid of a plant with medicinal benefits that has never killed anyone EVER but condone the use of alcohol (by not speaking against it's legality) for recreational purposes??
Another one who apparently has never witnessed someone going thru chemo/radiation….it’s not a pretty picture Alex, perhaps you should do a little research before you open your mouth and something else stupid falls out.
- Zizzy, Manchester
Unfortunately it is also viewed as a precursor to legalization of small amounts.
I don't think that we'll ever see capital punishment used or the legalization of pot. I hope I'm wrong on both counts.
- BA, Derry
- Dan, Auburn
I can't imagine any company would try to grow or import a supply knowing that such an activity is still in violation of federal law. Even if this bill passes, you're not going to be able to send a prescription to Express Scripts or CVS and receive some marijuana in exchange. What is the state's plan here?
What about insurance coverage? I doubt national health insurance companies are going to pay for something the federal government says is illegal.
Worse yet, is our tax money going to be used to keep welfare recipients' stashes filled? How do we make sure that there is no abuse? How are the people protected?
This all sounds great in theory, but I think there's a lot left unanswered.
- Alex, Nashua
- Tina, Bedford
- cleverdave, madison
Even 'potheads' know this
- Art, Portsmouth
For the dim bulbs out there up in arms at the thought of legal drugs, I have simple advice. Take a drive up Rt. 93 and see if you can notice the state of New Hampshire selling the legal, deadly, and addictive drug alcohol right on the highway! Let's not forget, the legal and deadly drug alcohol is the state drug. Let's also remember that even though drunk drivers kill someone in America every 45 minutes, the state of New Hampshire has no problem making it very easy to acquire this drug right off the interstate in multimillion dollar locations.
With governments starving for income, isn't it time they tapped into the pot goldmine, the largest cash crop in America? At the same time, savings in wasted enforcement and incarceration costs only sweeten the pot!
That pot, a far safer drug than alcohol, is still illegal, is one of the greater hypocrisies in our culture.
- Shndlr, Manchester, NH
I attended the testimony Tuesday in Concord, and even spoke. I believe the Senators, for the most part, want to pass HB648, but they don't see or hear from enough people coming forward and saying they need it or know someone who needs it. The Senators want to hear from the sick people and their families. They need to see just how big this problem really is!
Write a letter, write a post card, write an email, but do SOMETHING!!
The Senate will vote in 2 weeks then on to the Gov. There's only a week to mail something!
It's good to read what you have to say, and why you personally support medicinal marijuana but don't count on the Senators who actually vote on this to read your post here. Put it on paper and mail it to your Senator. It really does matter. That is how your voice and opinion will count.
Thank you to all the incredible people who are brave enough to do this... speak out! We are patients, not criminals.
Find out who to email or write to in your area on this site:
http://nhcompassion.org/content/take_action
- Kathy B., Laconia
I am glad that are legislature, and our culture is getting over this idea that all 'true' medicine comes in the form of a pill.
Most patients that have tried the pill form of THC complain that it is not as effective, and it contains 100% THC.
This ineffectiveness is mostly do to how long it takes for the THC in the pill to kick in, 30-40
min. Then the effect is typically unpredictable.
As far as smoked cannabis goes, not only does it contain THC (usually in the 4%-12% range) their are over 60 other cannibanoids that aid the therapeutic effect of the plant.
I am glad that the UL understands, and that the Legislature is learning, in a free country patients and doctors should make these decisions, not government.
- Phillip, Nashua
Marinol is available as a prescription drug, however, however Marinol is not natural cannabis. Marinol consists of a synthetic cannabinoid, synthetic THC. Although this pill does offer an alternative to ill patients, it is also important to note that Marinol is not necessarily a substitute for natural cannibis. Natural cannibis contains other cannabinoids that cause positive effects which are not found in Marinol. The effects of Marinol are also limited among a select group of patients. Again, natural cannabis may provide (and has been proven to do so) relief to patients not afforded to them with "conventional" prescription drugs. You must understand that although there are other drugs out there, they may not help, or help to the point cannabis does, in relief or they may provide greater pain and discomfort than good. And, for further clarification, patients will need to have tried other drugs and found them unable to help them in order to get a medical marijuana permit. The bill is written more strictly than has been seen in other states that have passed medical marijuana laws.
I would also caution how you see the passage of this bill. It is not to make all illegal drugs legal. In fact, I am sure that many people that support the legalization of medical marijuana use, or even marijuana use in general, may not support the legalization of all illegal drugs. Other illegal drugs have more clearly defined and observed effects on the human mind, psyche and overall well being. As has been said, marijuana cannot be overdosed on. In fact, it takes something like 20-40,000 times the regular dosage to kill someone, a number that is impossible to reach. There are reasons why it is illegal in this country, I dare say that it is not because of its bad effects.
If your argument is that marijuana is harmful, I challenge to ask you why you're not up in arms over the legality of tobacco and alcohol both of which do far greater damage to our country's citizens than marijuana does.
- Nichole, Middleton
- Correy, Goffstown
You would think so differently if you walked in their shoes. Count your blessings. Try harder to understand!
- Barbara Blanchette, Manchester
- Brian, Farmington
*** Editor's note: The Union Leader's editorial page has long supported the legal use of marijuana for limited medical reasons. ***
- dp, laconia
- Bruce, Derry
With respect to the UL's editorial, this caring and compassion campaign waged by the pro-legalization crowd for medical marijuana is just a stepping-stone towards full legalization of all illegal drugs. If you ask yourself why they insist on smoking marijuana instead of taking it as it already exists in pill form (Marinol), their motive becomes clear.
- Bryan, Nashua
- Deirdre, Goffstown
If someone that is dying or undergoing serious health issues/treatment needs to smoke some pot in order to be able to eat or alleviate some of the symptoms you think this is wrong? If you ever watched someone you loved be eaten away by cancer, and go through chemo that destroys their appetite and well being, you would think differently. If not, you are insensitve and without common sense.
And people that feel that because it is available in pill form means that it does not need to be cleared for patients to smoke? Eating the pot, or the drug has an entirely different effect on you than smoking it. You don't really get an increased appetite, therefor it is not effective in the same way as smoke.
- Mike, Manchester
- Mike, Bedford
- Zizzy, Manchester
The chemical itself is pretty benign, but the industry of prosecution is in it for the cash, the dealers are in it for the cash too. Take out the profit and problem is solved. Too liberal? Ok continue to fund crime with millions of our dollars, continue to divert millions of our ta dollars to enforcement. Load gun, shoot self in foot.
- Jose, Manchester
- DM, Hampton
- Brian, Farmington
- Mel, Hill
- Mike, Hooksett
While I disagree with specifics of the bill (I find it far too restrictive, and complying will be a hardship on patients), it is drastically better than the current status quo.
It is physically impossible to overdose on marijuana, unlike every drug approved by the FDA, and prescribed by doctors, for pain relief. Not to mention the over-the-counter pain relievers which are fatal if consumed to excess.
The negative side effects of marijuana are minimal, while the positives are numerous.
Marijuana prohibition has done far more damage to society than marijuana use ever could. To read the words of active and retired law enforcement officers who agree, please visit Law Enforcement Against Prohibition at www.leap.cc.
- Kevin, Lancaster
- Christian, Pawley's Island, SC
NOTE: If you have visited this page before, newer comments may be hidden. Press F5, or hold down the Ctrl key while reloading or refreshing the page. (Another option for Firefox users is the Clear Cache add-on.)