Home » Opinion » Editorials
Northern Pass: Too many towers
For months, Public Service of New Hampshire has dismissed the Northern Pass alternatives suggested by residents who did not want to see big transmission towers cut through their communities. And then a competitor came forward with a plan to build its own transmission lines - underground.
Almost immediately, PSNH backtracked. The company maintains that burying traditional power lines would be too expensive. But on Friday it hinted that maybe - just maybe - it could bury the type of line that National Grid has proposed for its Northeast Energy Link project.
National Grid and Bangor Hydro Electric would bury transmission lines to bring wind-generated power from Maine through New Hampshire into Massachusetts. With Northern Pass, Northeast Utilities (PSNH's parent company) and Hydro Quebec would bring hydropower from Quebec through New Hampshire and into Massachusetts.
Northern Pass is controversial because its towers would be 85 to 135 feet high and would cut through 40 miles of forests and communities where no lines exist.
Some other arguments are used by opponents. People say that the power won't go to New Hampshire or that hydro isn't really that "green." Those aren't serious arguments. New Hampshire buys power from what is available in the market, and Northern Pass would contribute to that. And hydro is a lot more reliable and no less "green" than wind. The real beef is with the towers.
The original Northern Pass plan would be the least costly to build and operate, and that is no small concern. But Northeast Utilities and Hydro Quebec will do better in the long run for both themselves and New Hampshire by opting instead for either buried lines in more sensitive areas or an alternative route through Vermont.
Almost immediately, PSNH backtracked. The company maintains that burying traditional power lines would be too expensive. But on Friday it hinted that maybe - just maybe - it could bury the type of line that National Grid has proposed for its Northeast Energy Link project.
National Grid and Bangor Hydro Electric would bury transmission lines to bring wind-generated power from Maine through New Hampshire into Massachusetts. With Northern Pass, Northeast Utilities (PSNH's parent company) and Hydro Quebec would bring hydropower from Quebec through New Hampshire and into Massachusetts.
Northern Pass is controversial because its towers would be 85 to 135 feet high and would cut through 40 miles of forests and communities where no lines exist.
Some other arguments are used by opponents. People say that the power won't go to New Hampshire or that hydro isn't really that "green." Those aren't serious arguments. New Hampshire buys power from what is available in the market, and Northern Pass would contribute to that. And hydro is a lot more reliable and no less "green" than wind. The real beef is with the towers.
The original Northern Pass plan would be the least costly to build and operate, and that is no small concern. But Northeast Utilities and Hydro Quebec will do better in the long run for both themselves and New Hampshire by opting instead for either buried lines in more sensitive areas or an alternative route through Vermont.
- Suppressing speech: Shea-Porter’s new attempt - 10
- Salinger’s bill: It goes way too far - 0
- First floor, pizza: Second floor, success - 0
- Goffstown consultant: Fees and free information - 0
- Ruling risk: Changes for the better - 0
- Paying for stupid: NH needs to send the message - 7
- Student loan distraction: College kids as political pawns - 21
- Obama and marriage: He ‘evolved’ back to his old position - 6
- Promoting trust: Fun with the Merrimack PD - 0
The income tax ban: Send it to the people
READER COMMENTS: 1- Bedford graduate credits her college success to IB - 1
- St. Casimir sixth graders build a scale model of City Hall - 0
- Man wants child porn evidence thrown out - 0
- Mark Thaler's H.S. Lacrosse: Don't underestimate emerging Goffstown - 0
- Kevin Gray's On Baseball: SNHU regional features some likely future pros - 0
- Dave D'Onofrio's Sox Beat: The dominant Beckett returns - 0
- No flashlight? Forget about that hike - 0
- Ex-girlfriend: I am fearful for my safety - 0
- HUD has few fans in regional planning - 0
Teacher cuts prompt pleas, explanation
READER COMMENTS: 3
Sorry, no question available


