Home » Opinion » Editorials
Occupying court: You say you want a revolution...
In district court for violating city curfew by camping in Manchester’s Victory Park, members of the Occupy New Hampshire movement argued last week that they were exercising both their First Amendment rights and their right to revolution under Part I, Article 10 of the New Hampshire Constitution. What we don’t understand is how the judge refrained from laughing for the entire day-long trial.
The First Amendment issue is already settled law. Time and place restrictions are perfectly acceptable. Nazis cannot block bridges in protest, no one can yell “fire” in a crowded theater just for kicks, and the First Amendment does not guarantee access to a specific public park at midnight.
The “revolution” argument is simply hilarious. The state constitution states that “whenever the ends of government are perverted, and public liberty manifestly endangered, and all other means of redress are ineffectual, the people may, and of right ought to reform the old, or establish a new government.”
The 17 Occupiers claim that their tiny protest vigil was intended as an act of revolution against the State of New Hampshire. But the constitution guarantees that right only under the circumstances outlined above, none of which has been met. A minority’s failure to get unpopular legislation passed does not amount to systematic governmental oppression. Sorry, Occupiers. If you want to enact your agenda, next time try running for office.
READER COMMENTS: 2
- John Stossel: Want to give back? Start a business - 7
- Ted Gatsas and Bob Baines: STEAM Ahead will transform students' lives in Manchester - 5
- Jonah Goldberg: No, Obamacare is not remotely close to fixed - 2
- George Will: A case for containing Iran - 0
- New Hampshire's long-term health continues to decline - 8
- Lou Catano: Non-profit directors know that NH is a special, giving place - 0
- Pat Buchanan: China has begun prowling Asia like a hungry tiger - 3
- Thomas Sowell: Victimhood and race - 4
- Fred Hiatt: While Obama talked, Assad killed - 4
READER COMMENTS: 0
- Two charged with selling heroin in Nashua - 0
- 'Fugitive of the week' arrested in Hooksett - 0
- Dover police arrest 3 on drug charges - 3
- Sports Briefs: No miracle finish for Vonn - 0
- Browns QB Campbell cleared to face Pats - 0
- Bruins defenseman Boychuk's status unknown - 0
- SNHU seeks NCAA title - 0
- Wildcat gridders visit Maine in defining game for program - 0
- Manchester needs more police department argues in staffing report - 4
Reams threatens to sue county commissioners
'Fugitive of the week' arrested in Hooksett
Dover police arrest 3 on drug charges
Conway is heartened by word of her letter
Nashua hero up for Carnegie award
McWages: They're about value
Pot debate precedes legislative hearings
Dingman: 'I try to be a better person'
John DiStaso's Granite Status: Scott Brown says 'nothing is really changed' on political plans