Home » Opinion » Editorials
Hailing the train: Better to let it pass
At their Monday debate in Nashua, Democratic candidates for governor Jackie Cilley, Maggie Hassan and Bill Kennedy concurred that one key to New Hampshire’s economic success would be shaped like a commuter train.
Such a fantasy is not confined to Democrats. Many Granite Staters are under the delusion that commuter rail is an unmitigated economic and transportation benefit.
There is a reason New Hampshire does not have commuter rail: It is that commuter rail in a state this sparsely populated is an enormous waste of resources. The state Department of Transportation studied the feasibility of adding a commuter rail line to I-93 when planning its expansion. The DOT opted to subsidize bus service instead. The department’s own study concluded that commuter rail was not cost-effective and would not reduce traffic congestion.
Commuter rail is a subsidy — on the order of hundreds of millions of dollars — to a tiny fraction of the mostly middle-class commuters who live in New Hampshire and work in Massachusetts.
There is no good case for building publicly subsidized commuter rail in New Hampshire at any time, and the case for it is made even weaker by our current economic situation. When the state struggles to fund its courts, prisons, highways and social services, the idea that we should devote scarce resources to a cushy ride to Boston for mid-level executives is preposterous.
At least Cilley and Kennedy suggest that they would raise taxes to bring this 19th-century commuting option to New Hampshire. Hassan pretends that we can avoid a broad-based tax and have commuter rail, too. The right option for New Hampshire is to avoid both.
READER COMMENTS: 0
- Page One Editorial: Control of NH’s future: Today’s House vote will be one for the ages - 17
- Consider Nevada: Gambling always expands - 9
- Missing the point: The IRS scandal and state power - 25
- Helping panhandlers: A method worth trying in Manchester - 7
- For the people: A century of the NH primary - 0
- What innovation? The casino way is the lazy way - 10
- Not so merry: Giving Robin Hood a bad name - 4
- Disengaged: Obama's lousy excuse - 15
- Underestimating NH: Gun control picks two wrong targets - 35
READER COMMENTS: 0
- Man wielding pipe robs Cumberland Farms in Goffstown - 0
- Buchholz moves to 7-0 as Red Sox post win - 0
- Gambling bill scuttled, 'Now it is going to be really tough' for budget - 25
- NHIAA Roundup: BG girls’ tennis team sweeps Pinkerton - 0
- NHIAA box scores, summaries for May 22 - 0
- Officials say Goffstown High ‘safe’ after threat of violence - 1
- Manchester Community College graduates told ‘speak your minds’ - 0
- Portsmouth manhunt suspect turns himself in to police - 0
- Nurse said Exeter Hospital is making her a ‘scapegoat’ in hepatitis case - 0
License revocations for DWI announced
Memorial Day events in New Hampshire
Consider Nevada: Gambling always expands