Home » News » Politics » Presidential Campaign
Judge: Voter ID law a no-go for Nov. 6
In a setback for Republican state officials who championed the controversial law and had hoped it would help them deliver Pennsylvania for their party's presidential nominee, Mitt Romney, Commonwealth Court Judge Robert Simpson delayed its implementation until after Election Day, Nov. 6.
Simpson, however, did signal the law, which requires people seeking to vote to show either a state driver's license, government employee ID or a state non-driver ID card, could be implemented for future elections. The judge, ordered by the state's highest court to revisit his earlier ruling upholding the law, set a hearing for Dec. 13 to further discuss the case.
The ruling comes exactly five weeks before the presidential election pitting challenger Romney against President Barack Obama, the Democratic nominee whom polls show has a sizable lead in the state. The closely watched case is also one of several challenges to recent laws around the country requiring voters to show proof of who they are and their eligibility to vote.
Simpson, who heard frustrated voters testify about the slow, mistake-prone process of obtaining the cards, said he had expected a greater number of identification cards to have been issued by now.
“For this reason, I accept (the) argument that in the remaining five weeks before the general election, the gap between the photo IDs issued and the estimated need will not be closed,” the judge said in an 18-page ruling.
“This is a victory for the petitioners and people who will be able to vote on Election Day,” said Marian Schneider, one of the attorneys for the voting rights and civil rights groups challenging the law.
Pennsylvania House Majority Leader Mike Turzai, a Republican who helped push the law through the Pennsylvania legislature this spring without a single Democratic vote, said he was pleased the law was upheld for future elections.
At a fundraiser in June, Turzai had touted it as a key achievement that would help the Romney camp this November, saying: “Voter ID, which is going to allow Governor Romney to win the state of Pennsylvania — done.”
Governor Tom Corbett, also a Republican and backer of the law, said he had no plans to appeal the decision handed down on Tuesday.
Corbett and other supporters say the law is aimed at ensuring only those legally eligible to vote cast ballots. Critics say it is designed to keep minority voters, who typically vote Democratic, away from the polls.
The state of Pennsylvania has acknowledged it has never seen a case of in-person voter fraud, according to court testimony.
- Should adultery remain a crime under U.S. military law?
- Yes
- 42%
- No
- 58%
- Total Votes: 641
John DiStaso's Granite Status
26
John DiStaso's Granite Status: Aide: 'Harry Reid doesn't speak for' Kelly Ayotte
0
John DiStaso's Granite Status: NH Dems 'welcome' back Scott Brown with 'Desperado' web ad
0
John DiStaso's Granite Status: Equipment manufacturers hire prominent NH attorney to fight dealers 'bill of rights'
7
John DiStaso's Granite Status: Just who is looking to build a New Hampshire casino?
0
John DiStaso's Granite Status: Gabrielle Giffords' gun control advocacy group critical of Ayotte in new radio ad
2
Granite Status: Guinta visits Washington as he weighs 2014 options
3
John DiStaso's Granite Status: Gatsas makes it official: seeking 3rd term as Manchester mayor
0
John DiStaso's Granite Status: Despite Sununu objection, Teamster official confirmed to state racing, charitable gaming panel
5
John DiStaso's Granite Status: Ovide Lamontagne headed to D.C. as Americans United for Life general counsel
3
John DiStaso's Granite Status: Gov Bobby Jindal coming to NH; 'Shaheen machine' raised $1.23M in Q1
0
John DiStaso's Granite Status: 'Casino Free NH': Pro-Hassan, but anti-gambling
5
John DiStaso's Granite Status: Jeb Bradley unfazed by possible Scott Brown US Senate run
0
John DiStaso's Granite Status: UNH Law's Rudman Center to host national conference on 'fiscal responsibility'
0
John DiStaso's Granite Status: NHDP to beef up communications team for 2014
0
John DiStaso's Granite Status: State GOP operatives split on how Priebus plan will affect NH, lesser-funded candidates
0
John DiStaso's Granite Status: Chris Sununu confirms he's eyeing governor or U.S. House run in '14
0
John DiStaso's Granite Status: Guinta re-emerges as founder, chair of new independent business advocacy group
0
John DiStaso's Granite Status: NH RNC member not alarmed by early moves to jumble 2016 presidential primary, caucus calendar
5
John DiStaso's Granite Status: New conservative advocacy group sends direct mail in Manchester Ward 2 special House election
0
John DiStaso's Granite Status: Ayotte among GOP senators invited to dine with Obama Wednesday evening
- Delaney Flanagan: Memories at the graveyard - 0
- Getting revved up over student car raffle - 0
- Man pulled from Barnstead pickup truck wreck with serious head injury - 0
- Boy Scouts of America vote ends gay scout ban - 0
- Warwick Mills scores $94.3 million contract from Army for body armor - 0
- Senate OKs medical pot, with plenty of restrictions - 0
- Rangers win in overtime, stay alive for Game 5 - 0
- Hanefeld shoots 74 at Senior PGA - 0
- Bishop Libasci to ordain 2 at St. Joseph Cathedral - 0
‘Back-door’ deal with wind farm loses in court
READER COMMENTS: 0Presidential Campaign » Events
- Should adultery remain a crime under U.S. military law?
- Yes
- 42%
- No
- 58%
- Total Votes: 641



