Nov 6, 2014
Oct 30, 2014
Oct 2, 2014
Sep 25, 2014
Officers in Greenland shootout ask judge to reconsider lawsuit
Cullen Mutrie, 29, had been barred from having weapons when he opened fire on police April 12, killing Greenland police Chief Michael Maloney. COURTESY
BRENTWOOD - Four police officers who filed a lawsuit against the mother of Cullen Mutrie say a pair of July 2010 police reports prove that she provided firearms to her son.
Lawyer Christopher Grant argued in Rockingham County Superior Court this week that the reports should be enough for Judge Kenneth McHugh to reconsider his decision that Beverly Mutrie cannot be held legally responsible for the deadly April 12 shootout her son had with police.
In his October decision, McHugh took issue with the officer's claims that Beverly Mutrie may have provided the weapons to her son, saying the lawsuit "did not contain any facts on how she did so."
Cullen Mutrie shot and killed Greenland police Chief Michael Maloney during a gun battle that ensued while Maloney and the officers attempted to execute a no-knock search warrant.
Moments after the shootout, Cullen Mutrie shot to death his ex-girlfriend and then killed himself.
The surviving officers claim in their lawsuit that Cullen Mutrie's mother, Beverly, can be held civilly liable because she supported her son financially and let him live in the Greenland house she owned. McHugh largely rejected that argument in October, saying he must dismiss the officer's claims due to a lack of evidence.
"Cullen Mutrie was 29 years old when he engaged in the firefight with police, and there is no evidence to support that (Beverly Mutrie) was in a position to control his actions," McHugh said in the order.
Grant argued in a request filed Thursday that Beverly Mutrie could be held responsible for her son's behavior because she owned the firearms and the Greenland home where the shooting took place.
"Property owners are responsible for and are liable for harm caused to others as a result of criminal conduct," Grant said in his argument.
Grant's request comes in advance of a Dec. 19 hearing so McHugh can decide whether the officers have any evidence that Beverly Mutrie provided firearms to her son.
The July 2010 reports summarize actions Greenland police undertook to seize weapons from Cullen Mutrie once an ex-girlfriend filed a protective order against him. Beverly Mutrie objected to police officers taking the weapons, saying they belonged to her, according to Grant.
Days later, police went to Beverly Mutrie's home in North Hampton - a home that her son frequented - and seized another 45 firearms, Grant said.
"(Beverly) Mutrie told us the guns belonged to her," Greenland Detective David Kurkul wrote in the July 27, 2010, report.
Police said they seized the weapons because Cullen Mutrie had access to them in defiance of the court's protective order.
READER COMMENTS: 0
- Manchester police investigating after man stabbed in neck - 1
- Ferguson protests enter third day; arrests in St. Louis - 0
- Abuse history at Nashua address where 3-year-old died - 7
- Franklin robbery suspect sought, considered armed and dangerous - 0
- Franklin man and woman arraigned for attempted prostitution of minor - 1
- Police investigating death of 3-year-old girl in Nashua - 7
- Police say hit-and-run driver was observed tossing beer cans from car - 0
- Police say woman stole pocketbook at Hudson Market Basket - 0
- Police say former manager of Hudson McDonald's stole $10k from restaurant - 1
READER COMMENTS: 1
- Bruins pleased with start in spite of injuries - 0
- Celtics Insider: Celtics rule Smart out of tomorrow's game against Chicago - 0
- Berube the backbone of Monarchs' team 'D' - 0
- Packers QB Revis will pose a challenge for Patriots - 3
- Hudson may start charging for non-transport ambulance calls - 2
- NH suffers 4th worst outage on record - 15
- Camping out didn't pay for shoppers - 0
- Newsreel: Concord economic forecast; Tech Council hosts forum; UNH Fairchild Dairy honored - 0
- Londonderry-based MegaFood launches transparency project in vitamin industry - 0
NH suffers 4th worst outage on record
Camping out didn't pay for shoppers
NH suffers 4th worst outage on record
Pat Buchanan: What to make of Ferguson?
- Whom do you think bears the brunt of the blame for the mayhem this weekend in Keene?
- KSC students
- KSC administration
- Visitors from out of town
- A combination of any/all of the above
- Total Votes: 2483