Home » Opinion » Editorials
Tax dollars draining: What's a floodway for?
To Missouri lawmakers, it's a common-sense community development project. To what seems like almost everyone else, it's a bizarre waste of taxpayer money and an ecological disaster that a few members of Congress refuse to drop.
The New Madrid Floodway is a strip of land along the Mississippi River in Missouri's "bootheel." The Army Corps of Engineers dumps water into it when the river threatens to flood the city of Cairo, Ill., as it did in 2011. People nevertheless farm the land in the floodway, and they want the Corps to help them do it. Backed by their representatives in Congress, they demand a $165 million project to, yes, prevent too much flooding in the floodway.
There is a 1,500-foot gap in the local levee at the bottom of the floodway. That gap allows water to exit when the Corps purposely inundates the area. But the gap also allows water into the floodway at other times, resulting in unintentional flooding. Residents want the Corps to close the gap and blow a hole at the bottom of the levee when it needs to use the floodway. In years in which the floodway isn't needed - most, so far - that would increase agricultural yields and, no doubt, local land values.
In other words, they want the federal government to spend taxpayer money encouraging economic activity in a zone it is obligated to flood during high-water events. It should be no surprise that the locals are putting up none of their own cash to pay for the project. Also unsurprising is the alarm of Cairo's mayor, who worries that building up the floodway meant to protect his city would make it harder to strategically inundate that area and so spare his residents.
Taxpayer advocates and environmentalists are raising the alarm. The project would drain a whopping 41,000 acres of wetlands in one of the last places along the lower Mississippi that still has them. When the water flows through that gap in the levee, fish and waterfowl follow along, using the habitat to spawn and feed. The Corps has claimed that it can offset the damage, but environmentalists - and regulators at other government agencies - have strongly disagreed with its assessments.
The New Madrid Floodway project has been on the table since at least 1954, and it nearly got built decades later - until a federal judge tossed it in 2007. The Corps is completing a new analysis - its seventh - claiming the plan would result in modest economic gains for those in the area, and Sen. Roy Blunt, R-Mo., is threatening to hold up the confirmation of President Obama's next Environmental Protection Agency chief if the administration doesn't proceed quickly.
Instead, Mr. Obama should finally kill the project.
READER COMMENTS: 2
- Katie McQuaid's Scene in Manchester: Elm Street's resurgence includes a good workout - 0
- Katie McQuaid's Scene in Manchester: Calling all area Muchachos - 0
- Scene in Manchester: Runners get ready to travel back in time - 0
- Katie McQuaid's Scene in Manchester: Bootcamp takes chocolate to a new level - 0
- Katie McQuaid's Scene in Manchester: Dinner offers delicious way to honor local farmers - 0
- Katie McQuaid's Scene in Manchester: Cyclists work to ride safely on city streets - 1
- Scene in Manchester: We're getting older, and it's time for NH to talk about it - 3
- Katie McQuaid's Scene in Manchester: Sing (even badly) for a truly great cause - 0
- Katie McQuaid's Scene in Manchester: Time to lace up and hit the road - 0
READER COMMENTS: 0
- Fleeing hostile states: Gun makers will travel - 0
- Voting in NH: Not just for NH residents - 0
- Owl's Nest hosting NH Open starting Wednesday - 0
- 57th Red Ryan tourney starts today at Derryfield - 0
- Graveman hurls Fisher Cats to victory - 0
- Cabrera, Blue Jays trounce fading Red Sox - 1
- Former city police officer faces charges in drug case - 0
- Chinese citizen held on $50,000 cash bail in car case - 0
- Man found unconscious with head injury on city sidewalk - 0
Gorham man arrested for kidnapping Abigail
Cabrera, Blue Jays trounce fading Red Sox
Dover patient shocked by $3,766 Wentworth-Douglass charged insurer for tube of cold sore cream
Bikers say under-30 generation isn't interested, and can't afford many of the top motorcycles
Graveman hurls Fisher Cats to victory
Voting in NH: Not just for NH residents
Gorham man arrested for kidnapping Abigail