Oct 2, 2014
Sep 25, 2014
Sep 18, 2014
Sep 4, 2014
AG clears Nashua chief of credibility issue in murder testimony
Seusing was a key investigator in the case against Michael Monroe, who was ultimately convicted of second-degree murder in the stabbing death his mother-in-law Theresa Levesque, 66, in her Nashua home on March 6, 1993.
Anthony Pivero, a former Nashua police officer, complained to the attorney general in March claiming Seusing had been disciplined for a dishonesty issue in an unrelated arrest in 1984 or 1985 that later led to a lawsuit, and that should have been disclosed to the defense before the Monroe murder trial.
"The investigation established that Chief Seusing was untruthful to a superior more than 25 years ago and, he, of his own volition, corrected his error and received his punishment," which was a 15-day suspension, Attorney General Joseph Foster said in a news release issued Thursday.
Seusing said: "Twenty-seven years ago I was a young officer with a few years on the job and I made a terrible mistake, one that I certainly regret to this day.
"I can't change that, but I owned up to it on my own. I was disciplined for it, and the discipline was well-deserved."
Seusing said it was unfortunate that the situation was brought up nearly three decades after the fact, but he understands that individuals in his position are held to a higher standard.
"A lot of time people make mistakes and they don't put a lot of thought into it. You take your punishment and you move on, and that is what I have done," said Seusing, adding the personnel matter was dealt with 27 years ago. "And everybody knew about it at the time."
Seusing admits it was a terrible mistake, but said he learned from the error and put it behind him a long time ago.
Police departments must tell prosecutors if a police officer has information in his or her personnel file that could impact a jury's assessment of the officer's credibility as a witness, the release said. Prosecutors then have a constitutional obligation to disclose such information called "Laurie" issues to the defense.
Pivero had alleged that Seusing fabricated a police report when he was a patrol officer in a 1984 or 1985 case, the release said.
"The review however established that while Seusing failed to tell the truth to his superiors when a complaint arose from his arrest, he later corrected his mistake of his own volition," the release said.
In his March complaint, Pivero questioned whether it was disclosed in the Monroe murder, in which Seusing testified.
"Upon review by this office, Pivero's allegations proved largely incorrect. Seusing did not author a false report and did not provide false testimony," the release said.
Seusing lied to superiors when asked if he had made an arrest and he said no, but later corrected himself, the release said.
The matter was fully vetted by the superior court during pretrial hearings in the Monroe trial in 1995, the release said. The state successfully argued then the incident "presents precious little, if any, probative value, which is substantially outweighed by its potential to mislead or confuse the jury, while prejudicing the state." The judge ultimately denied the defense motion to submit the evidence in Seusing's confidential personnel file.
Associate Attorney General Jane Young said the investigation revealed three other cases in which the defense should be told about Seusing's discipline. The release said Seusing and the Nashua police department fully cooperated.
The release said: "In order to satisfy our legal and ethical obligations, this office will continue to apprise defendants of this incident involving Chief Seusing, and we will continue to vigorously argue, as this office successfully did in 1995, that this incident is not proper impeachment evidence."
READER COMMENTS: 2
- Ex-Seabrook police officer wants to keep sealed statements out of trial - 0
- Hollis police investigating thefts from vehicles - 0
- Hooksett woman charged with child sex assault - 0
- Manchester Crimewatch: Stalking charge filed after court appearance - 0
- 2 men charged with stealing $210k in cash from Salem home - 0
- Two indicted for possession, intent to sell spice - 0
- Guardianship sought for Middleton man accused in standoff - 0
- Deliberations continue in Dover fatal stabbing trial - 0
- Suspect identified in shooting at Canada's Parliament - 0
READER COMMENTS: 0
- Islanders make Boychuk's return a happy one with 3-2 win - 0
- Police say driver in Amherst fatal crash was traveling about 45 mph above limit - 0
- Stocks rally on better-than-expected earnings - 0
- Apple leaves door open for GT Advanced - 0
- Nashua dealing with roadway flooding - 0
- Shaheen, Brown clash over handling of Ebola threat - 4
- FairPoint finds lines cut, calls it 'sabotage' - 0
- UPDATED: Flood warning issued for southern NH; leaks force visitation to be cancelled at Goffstown women's prison - 2
- Dead racoon found in Derry tests positive for rabies - 0
UPDATED: Flood warning issued for southern NH; leaks force visitation to be cancelled at Goffstown women's prison
Win tickets to see Kip Moore
Fixing Obamacare: Shaheen offers no way out
Blackwater verdict stuns NH dad
Making it up: Shameless state Senate attacks
- Whom do you think bears the brunt of the blame for the mayhem this weekend in Keene?
- KSC students
- KSC administration
- Visitors from out of town
- A combination of any/all of the above
- Total Votes: 2483