Home » Opinion » Editorials
An NSA setback: Fourth Amendment wins first round
The argument for the constitutionality of this massive phone record data collection rests upon Smith v. Maryland, a 1979 case in which the Supreme Court ruled that people had no expectation of privacy in the records kept by phone companies. But Leon reasoned that a) phones are used differently today and produce enough data to compile a profile of each user, something not possible in 1979, and b) the government's collection and keeping of all the data is itself unreasonable.
Exactly. The state has not, and never should have, that power. All Americans should hope the appellate courts agree.
READER COMMENTS: 0
- Physician reprimanded after baby’s brain damaged in delivery - 0
- Police obtain warrants for suspect wanted in Dover, Manchester bank robberies - 0
- Abby Dion, 9, records a 10 in gymnastics meet - 0
- St. A skaters fall to Norwich - 0
- Monarchs lose in OT; win streak stops at 6 - 0
- Police searching for person stealing from cars in Manchester - 1
- College Football: Maine seniors want the coveted musket - 0
- College Hockey: Ice-making problem postpones UNH-PC - 1
- Pinkerton backfield a combination of power and speed - 0
Jury acquits Mont Vernon driver, who was checking text, in death of former Amherst fire chief
Offend someone? To jail with you!
Obama to illegals: Come out of shadows
Plaistow town planner arrested
A kinder, gentler House Speaker?
Driver acquitted in Amherst ex-chief’s death
Pipeline's NH route moves to top choice
College Hockey: Providence blanks UNH