In NH debate, no common ground found on Common Core
Both sides came to the table at the New Hampshire Institute of Politics at St. Anselm College to explore whether Common Core education standards are good for Granite State families. About 150 people heard panelists explain their support or opposition to the federally-developed standards at the event hosted by Cornerstone Action and Cornerstone Policy Research.
Opponents criticized the standards and the process that brought Common Core to this state.
Jamie Gass, Boston-based Director of the Center for School Reform at Pioneer Institute, said his organization did independent analysis of Common Core. He told the audience that Massachusetts owes much of its history of academic success to a deep commitment to classic literature, drama and poetry. Common Core, he said, represents a dramatic shift away from classic literature toward informational texts and non-fiction.
“The quality of the language and vocabulary is significantly better than informational texts and nonfiction that Common Core offers,” Gass said.
Since Massachusetts is one of the highest performing states in the nation and New Hampshire is right behind, both have a great deal to lose in term of quality of education, Gass said.
Emmett McGroarty, executive director of Education at American Principles Project, argued the core’s math standards replace traditional algorithms with strategies, leaving children behind their counterparts in other high-performing countries.
“If it weren’t so sad it would be comical,” McGroarty said.
Ann Marie Bandfield, education researcher and education liaison for Cornerstone Action, said the standards set for younger students were inappropriate.
“Asking children to abstract think in lower grades sets up a stressful situation for children,” Banfield said.
But David Pook, a teacher at the Derryfield School and Granite State College and who was a contributing writer or the Common Core English Language Arts standards, disagreed on both points.
“The goal is to have kids read closely, examine complex texts and compare required skills,” Pook said. “Any sensible school in society would have their kids be able to do this.”
Tom Raffio, Chairman of the state Board of Education, which has endorsed Common Core, presented comments from educators across the state supporting Common Core.
Many teachers felt it was beneficial to know what students learned the previous years and what to expect from students transferring in from other districts.
“It was a very inclusive process and we’ve seen the results,” Raffio said.
READER COMMENTS: 0
- Franklin Pierce University's credit downgraded - 0
- Fidelity employees give Nashua school a makeover - 0
- Pinkerton prepares for headmaster to live on campus - 0
- Three named to Manchester school posts - 0
- Derry Early Education Program to relocate - 0
- Manchester panel OKs new academic standards, despite Common Core criticism - 2
- Nashua school staff see tests as key to tracking student growth - 0
- Two Manchester schools off 'priority' list - 0
- Nashua officials seek advice on issue of student cellphone searches vs. privacy - 9
READER COMMENTS: 0
- On Baseball: Fishers prospects sweat out deadline day - 0
- Goffstown ready for LL regional tourney - 0
- Dave D'Onofrio's Sox Beat -- Message is clear: Offense needs boost - 0
- Marina dealers say boat sales are on the rise - 0
- Another View -- Gilles Bissonnette: Why voting in NH is not reserved for state residents - 0
- John Stossel: Healthy profits? - 0
- Clinton vs. speech: Bullying first; what next? - 0
- Another View - Charles Lane: Your money is being spent by dead people - 0
- Race matters: A cautionary tale at UNH - 0
Havenstein says he has always opposed Obamacare, though company he led was paid to implement parts of it
George Will: A conservative internationalism
Heroes all? A word cheapened by overuse
Mark Hayward's City Matters: Market Basket workers' outlook challenges the skeptics among us
Market Basket customers mobilize
Punch line: The NFL blows it
Police held Abby suspect's guns