Had a bad experience at Newark Liberty Airport last year? You’re not alone, according to recent rankings.
The New Jersey hub ranked as the worst U.S. airport in the 2019 annual ratings from AirHelp, an organization that specializes in air traveler rights and seeks compensation in cases of delays or cancellations.
U.S. airports in general didn’t fare particularly well, with the highest-rated Hartsfield-Jackson Atlanta International Airport taking 34th place of 132 around the world. Newark held the lowest U.S. spot, at 116. One reason is weather-related delays, said Henrik Zillmer, AirHelp’s CEO.
“If you have the slightest amount of snow at JFK, the airport will close,” Zillmer said, referring to the New York hub that ranked 86th. Beyond that, quality of service in the U.S. has room for improvement, with long security lines a frequent problem.
The airports are rated based on three factors: on-time performance, service quality, and food and shopping options. The first accounts for 60 percent of the score and the other criteria each make up 20 percent. AirHelp’s data come from multiple commercial vendors, along with its own database, plus 40,000 passenger surveys collected in 40 countries during 2018.
Topping AirHelp’s rankings are Hamad International Airport in Doha, Qatar; Tokyo International Airport; and Athens International Airport, which have taken the top spots since the ratings began in 2015. It’s worth considering the overall picture of each airport in looking at the list. For instance, high ratings for Athens puzzled the AirHelp team at first, says Zillmer, until you consider that its sunny weather results in fewer delays, and vacationers are more likely to leave positive reviews.
“It’s a good efficient airport, there are a lot of things I like about it,” says Scott Mayerowitz, executive editorial director at travel website the Points Guy, about Athens International, but noted there’s nothing inspiring about it. The fact that at just works seems to be enough, even without bells and whistles such as a butterfly gardens or ‘rain vortex.’ “At the end of the day, you’re not going to choose a destination because it’s got a great airport-you’re choosing a destination because you’re either going to that place for vacation or you have business meetings there.”
But when you do have choice, as in the New York City metro area, it can factor in.
“Newark is traditionally one of the worst performing airports in the country and one that travelers avoid because of the delays there,” says Mayerowitz. He also expressed surprise at Billy Bishop Toronto City airport being ranked so low, as opposed to Pearson, noting it’s a favorite of business travelers who love its convenience to the city center. “I thought it should have been higher.”
Congestion continues to be the biggest problem facing airports: The flight industry is experiencing a rapid increase in global tourism. The Worldwide Tourism Organization estimates that worldwide international tourist arrivals increased 6%, to 1.4 billion in 2018.
“Some airports are expanding quickly, but it’s still a big issue for most, especially during peak hours,” says Zillmer.
10 Best Airports of 2019
Hamad International Airport, Qatar (DOH)
Tokyo International Airport, Japan (HND)
Athens International Airport, Greece (ATH)
Afonso Pena International Airport, Brazil (CWB)
Gdansk Lech Walesa Airport, Poland (GDN)
Sheremetyevo International Airport, Russia (SVO)
Changi Airport Singapore, Singapore (SIN)
Rajiv Gandhi International Airport, India (HYD)
Tenerife North Airport, Spain (TFN)
Viracopos/Campinas International Airport, Brazil (VCP)
10 Worst Airports of 2019
London Gatwick Airport, United Kingdom (LGW)
Billy Bishop Toronto City Airport, Canada (YTZ)
Porto Airport, Portugal (OPO)
Paris Orly Airport, France (ORY)
Manchester Airport, United Kingdom (MAN)
Malta International Airport, Malta (MLA)
Henri Coanda International Airport, Romania (OTP)
Eindhoven Airport, Netherlands (EIN)
Kuwait International Airport, Kuwait (KWI)
Lisbon Portela Airport, Portugal (LIS)
Among the 72 airlines for which the company has statistically significant data, AirHelp rated them by on-time performance, service quality, and claim processing, with each category weighed equally.
For the second year in a row, Qatar Airways ranked as the top airline, followed by American Airlines, Aeromexico, SAS Scandinavian Airlines, and Qantas in the top five. At the bottom of the list were Ryanair, Korean Air, Kuwait Airways, and the U.K.’s EasyJet and Thomas Cook Airlines.
Better weather conditions led to fewer flight disruptions in 2018 overall, Zillmer said, with on-time performance improving across the board. This may have contributed to American Airlines securing the second-place spot — a big jump, considering that the airline ranked 23rd last year.
“I was a little surprised to see Korean Air be so far down,” said Scott Mayerowitz, executive editorial director at travel website The Points Guy. “It’s one of Asia’s best airlines.” He wonders at American’s jump as well, noting its struggles with on-time performance and customer satisfaction. (American Airlines reps declined to comment on this ranking.)
United Airlines Inc. and Delta Air Lines Inc. were also significantly higher in 2018 than in 2017, respectively ranking 16th and 17th, compared to 37th and 47th. While Aeromexico went from 26th to 3rd place, SAS Scandinavian Airlines jumped to 4th from from 36th, and Air France climbed up 15 spots to 34th.
Zillmer said one area in which many airlines need to improve is claim-processing operations, which tidily wraps into the mission of AirHelp. Instead of canceling a flight as soon as it’s clear that a plane won’t be able to fly, many force passengers to wait in the airport during long flight delays. “They’re not economically incentivized to put you on a different airline to get you to your destination,” he said. He said he hopes that rankings like this can shed light on how airlines are falling short and motivate them to step up service.
Here are the best and worst airlines of the year, with on-time performance records.
10 Best Airlines of 2019
Qatar Airways (84 percent)
American Airlines (75 percent)
Aeromexico (78 percent)
SAS Scandinavian Airlines (73 percent)
Qantas (79 percent)
LATAM Airlines (77 percent)
WestJet (74 percent)
Luxair (78 percent)
Austrian Airlines (71 percent)
Emirates (75 percent)
10 Worst Airlines of 2019
Adria Airways (67 percent)
Aerolineas Argentinas (80 percent)
Transavia (62 percent)
Laudamotion (51 percent)
Norwegian (70 percent)
Ryanair (65 percent)
Korean Air (69 percent)
Kuwait Airways (42 percent)
EasyJet (67 percent)
Thomas Cook Airlines (57 percent)