CONCORD — A middle-aged White man living in rural New Hampshire lost his bid Monday to force state officials to scrap priorities that provide the COVID-19 vaccine to disadvantaged minorities, given the higher-than-average impact they suffer from the disease.


In a 24-page order, U.S. District Court Judge Paul Barbadoro refused to issue an injunction sought by James Pietrangelo II, 55, who lives in Glen, a village in the White Mountain town of Bartlett.

Pietrangelo filed suit in federal court to block Gov. Chris Sununu and other state officials from implementing a distribution plan that favored anyone based on race, ethnicity or minority-group status.

In his order, Barbadoro noted that minorities are eligible for priority only if they live in the 25% of state census tracts deemed most vulnerable to COVID-19 impacts. Pietrangelo has not proven that he would get the vaccine faster if the equity plan priorities were not in place, the judge wrote.

“Bartlett, where he resides, is a very low vulnerability tract that is not even close to the top 25% most vulnerable tracts,” Barbadoro wrote.

As of Feb. 23, between 4 and 5% of the state’s vaccine supply had been provided under the state’s equity plan to residents of homeless shelters, senior housing locations, soup kitchens, community health centers, low-income housing, rescue missions and similar locations, Barbadoro reported.

The state’s distribution plan called for distributing up to 10% of vaccines under the equity guidelines. But state officials have never reached that benchmark because the population it aims to vaccinate is hard to identify and reach.

Thursday, April 15, 2021
Wednesday, April 14, 2021