“THE TEST OF a first-rate intelligence,” F. Scott Fitzgerald famously wrote, “is the ability to hold two opposed ideas in mind at the same time and still retain the ability to function.”


I make no claim to being a first-rate intelligence. I’m not even sure I can claim to function on many days. But that’s OK, since Washington has elevated mere functioning to an unattainable ideal.

Regardless, I find myself sympathetic to two ideas that partisans consider to be in open conflict. On one hand, I think it’s obvious that President Trump committed impeachable offenses. He suspended congressionally authorized military aid to Ukraine in an attempt to pressure the Ukrainian government to advance his narrow political interest. He wasn’t interested in exposing corruption; he was interested in getting a foreign government to tar a political opponent as corrupt.

The President is constitutionally bound by oath to faithfully execute the laws. Trump didn’t do that. That he abandoned the scheme only when he thought he’d be caught is not an exoneration, but evidence of intent.

Further, by trying to get the Ukrainians to propagate a lie that, according to his former homeland security adviser, has “no validity” and has been “completely debunked,” the President abused his power. According to the CrowdStrike canard, Ukraine, not Russia, hacked the Democratic National Committee’s server and released embarrassing emails that undermined the Hillary Clinton campaign.

Trump believes that the DNC’s server is really in Ukraine, hidden there by the Ukrainian co-owner of the digital security firm CrowdStrike, which the DNC hired to examine the hacking of the DNC server.

The problems with this are too lengthy to recount here, but the co-owner of CrowdStrike (an American firm) isn’t Ukrainian, and there was no single “DNC server” — there are many, and they were never taken to Ukraine. Moreover, why Ukraine would expose campaign emails to help Clinton is never explained.

The CrowdStrike stuff is Russian and Trumpist propaganda. Russian President Vladimir Putin wants to frame Ukraine as a way to further isolate the beleaguered nation he’s waging war upon. Trump believes that the proven Russian hacking of the DNC and other meddling undermines the glory of his election.

By the way, the National Republican Congressional Committee, the campaign arm of House Republicans, is a CrowdStrike client — which you’d think would bother the Republican congressmen pretending there’s legitimacy behind the CrowdStrike nonsense.

Now for the other hand. The Democrats want to rush to impeachment based on a political calendar that would have them skip the steps required to fully make their case. The sole Republican witness in Wednesday’s House Judiciary Committee hearing on impeachment, George Washington University law professor Jonathan Turley, made a strong case that the impeachment strategy the Democrats are pursuing is deeply flawed.

“If you’re going to accuse a President of bribery, you need to make it stick, because you’re trying to remove a duly elected President of the United States,” Turley testified.

Former national security adviser John Bolton, acting White House chief of staff Mick Mulvaney and Trump fixer Rudy Giuliani should testify before Congress if we’re to get all of the facts out. The White House won’t let them testify and has gone to court to prevent it. The Democratic response is to preemptively forgo any effort to contest that decision and skip ahead to the claim that their refusal to testify voluntarily is an abuse of power.

“If you make a high crime and misdemeanor out of going to the courts, it is an abuse of power. It’s your abuse of power,” Turley said.

While Turley didn’t fully acknowledge that the White House is acting in bad faith by complaining about the process while refusing to participate in the process at all — it won’t even provide exculpatory documents, likely because they don’t exist — he nonetheless makes a good point.

Democrats are hampered by the fact that many of them have been banging the impeachment drums since the day Trump was elected. Their belief that they’ve finally got him dead to rights doesn’t absolve them of the responsibility of going through all of the motions to prove their good faith, even if that might be unpopular or mess up their political timetable.

Their process isn’t a “hoax” or “show trial,” but reasonable people can be forgiven for feeling like the Democrats are trying to railroad a guilty man. That’s a bad precedent, regardless of whether you agree with me that Trump is guilty.

Monday, February 17, 2020
  • Updated

IN THE SEVEN presidential elections since 1992, the Republican presidential nominee has won the popular vote exactly once. The lone GOP candidate to receive a majority of the national vote was George W. Bush in 2004. Bush’s election-day victory over Democrat John Kerry, who had, in most obse…

  • Updated

MATT SCHLAPP, chairman of the American Conservative (cough) Union, which hosts the annual CPAC conference, tweeted that he was disinviting Mitt Romney from the confab this year because he “could not guarantee his physical safety” after the senator voted to convict Donald Trump in the impeach…

Saturday, February 15, 2020
  • Updated

FROM the day he entered the race, Joe Biden was the great hope of the Democratic establishment to spare them from the horrifying prospect of a 2020 race between The Donald and Bernie Sanders.

Friday, February 14, 2020
Thursday, February 13, 2020
Wednesday, February 12, 2020
  • Updated

“SHOUT OUT, do not hold back! Lift up your voice like a trumpet!” said the prophet Isaiah, which we read in church on Sunday, but nobody shouted. We are flatlanders, brought up to be still and behave ourselves and listen to instructions, but if the instruction is to shout out and raise your …

Tuesday, February 11, 2020

LAST MONDAY’S Iowa caucuses were an epic failure for Democrats. Thanks to a star-crossed ballot-tabulation program written by alumni of the Obama and Hillary Clinton campaigns, final results were still unavailable as of early Thursday morning. The party that is desperate to control every Ame…

It’s comforting, no doubt, to believe that Donald Trump has survived the impeachment trial because he possesses a tighter hold on his party than did Barack Obama or George W. Bush or any other contemporary president. In truth, Trump, often because of his own actions, has engendered less loya…

During his floor speech explaining his vote to convict Donald Trump, Mitt Romney was overcome by emotion and paused to compose himself. The intense moment came when he spoke of his devotion to God, saying: "I am profoundly religious. My faith is at the heart of who I am." Lump in throat. Lon…

Sunday, February 09, 2020

JUST AS he has done throughout his business career and personal life, Donald Trump bullied his way through being only the third President in history to be impeached. He was not removed from office by the Senate — not because he was found “not guilty”, but because he threatened, stonewalled a…

Saturday, February 08, 2020
Friday, February 07, 2020

Jonah Goldberg is editor-in-chief of The Dispatch and the host of The Remnant podcast. His Twitter handle is @JonahDispatch.